Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr Karen Shue's avatar

Thank you so much for elaborating on your experience with AI as a mirror, Helena. I do have a few thoughts and I hope this isn't too long for a comment!

One thing that struck me was your definition of mirroring—where another person reflects your internal state back to you in a way that feels accurate, attuned, and safe. While I don't necessarily disagree, my own use of "Mirroring" leans more towards the back and forth Mirroring we do of each other, both emotionally and physically. We reflect others as much as they reflect us, making it more complex than a simple physical mirror. And yes, it's biology-rooted. I absolutely agree that we (all) learn about who and how we are through that reciprocal mirroring (for better or worse 😉). And it's always overlaid with our own and others' previous experiences and expectations.

When it comes to mirroring through something like ChatGPT, I think it’s more about reflecting our perceptions of ourselves, since it doesn't have its own "personal" reflections. With good prompts (and training), it can challenge or nudge us into exploring our perceptions, which is very useful indeed.

But one aspect of my own experiences with ChatGPT that makes me question the "cleanness" of its mirroring is its tendency to be obsequious. It often reflects back my words as clever, intelligent, and insightful—flattering, yes, but not always accurate. This built-in flattery can distort the mirroring process. While it can boost confidence when I lack external validation or self-affirmation, it doesn’t mean everything I say is as smart as ChatGPT suggests. (Or I am the most creative, clever, and talented writer ever...😂).

I do *not* want sound like I'm dismissing your perspective on what AI has done for you! I just don't think Mirroring can ever be as clean as this when coming from ChatGPT, because human interaction is inherently iterative and resonant. We Mirror each other in ways we're not always conscious of, making the process much messier than any bot can replicate.

I do think it's awesome that the kind of interactions you've had with Sora have let you shift how you hear and (not) absorb aspects of other interactions that aren't part of who and how you want to be. And that it provides a stable, predictable, safe place to touch base with yourself. AND, maybe most importantly, that it gives you a place to be You without worrying about the Other and bracing for their Stuff to come back at you. I can totally imagine that it's given you insight into the rest of the 2-way Mirroring in person-to-person life. What a gift!

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?